In short I think the Guild changes are a good thing, they will impact players who guild hop massively, after a while they’ll remain at a permanent disadvantage for some of the upper perks but that’s the downside of never really committing to a guild. Even after factoring in the current boost to Guild XP on the beta it looks like that decent progression will be possible even in the most modest of guilds, which is good news for my $HOME guild which I think will boast a mighty 15 active members come Cataclysm.
Having never been a GM I’ve been playing around with the interface a bit (images below), which is feeling pretty nice, a few edges which I would prefer to be done a different way but nothing which is horrible or game breaking.
